Get Smart, DVD Recorders That Is

by Roger Wyatt
Summer/Fall 2003

What's So Smart?
"That's the trouble...I haven't got a brain...only straw." The Scarecrow in The Wizard of Oz might be saying what your DVD player is thinking (if it had a brain, of course). Sure the DVD player is smarter than the old VHS VCR, but without a computer, are either of them really smart? I need to record this show, but I want to check out the program I recorded last night. I guess I need two machines for that. My video gear needs more smarts. Besides there's getting to be an awful lot of electronics boxes in here. Can't some of these functions be combined into one device? Why can't they combine a DVD, PVR, and a VCR into one device? Now that would be smart.

Well, wake up and smell the coffee. This is the year of the smart DVD. Throughout 2003, consumer electronics manufactures will roll out model after model of smart DVD recorders. This new breed of recorders functions as VCR replacements, burning television and home videos onto recordable DVD discs. If that was all there was it would be great. After all, fifty DVDs take up a lot less space than fifty VHS tapes. But there's even more. Recording with DVD media has serious advantages, such as simultaneous recording and playback from the same disc. Try that with VHS. Want more? How about instant random access? As you know, DVDs don't need to rewind or fast forward like tape. With instant recording onto a DVD disc, there's no need to find blank space like with tape. Press record and the unit will automatically find space on the disc, just like a hard drive does. The media holds 4.7GB of video with accompanying audio, which can translate into an hour (or more) of content. Compared to videotape, DVD has a vastly increased lifetime of the media itself.

With many of the machines being introduced having a list price of around $600, Smart DVD recorders will reinvent home taping and viewing. They offer easy recording and editing from broadcast programs via antenna, cable or satellite receiver. With Smart DVD recorders, you can watch what you want, when you want to watch it. You can even watch last week's episode while recording this week's from the same disc at the same time. That's Digi-VooDoo, isn't it?

Smart Features
A smart DVD recorder most likely will include some, if not all of the following: an Electronic Program Guide, basic editing capabilities, FireWire input, Internet access, a hard drive and support for the multiple DVD formats. Let's take a closer look.

  • Electronic program guide: Forget the blinking 12:00 on the front of your VCR. With no-fee interactive program guides, like GUIDE Plus+, one-touch recording is a reality. RCA and Philips have good examples of this feature.
  • FireWire input: This is a great way to transfer camcorder material or home videos on to DVD. Just connect from the FireWire port of your DV camcorder direct to the same port on the Smart DVD recorder. Whether your system calls that connection FireWire or i.LINK, or IEEE-1394, no matter, they are all the same digital interface standard. Models from Sony, Philips, Pioneer, and M.E.T. (CyQ've) have this feature.
  • Basic editing capability: Got a few favorite VHS tape recordings? Something you shot at a wedding or on vacation? You can easily transfer it to space-saving discs. Your personal library of family video stuff can be archived, preserved, easily cataloged, accessed and even edited right from the disc. Models from Sony and Toshiba are strong in this area.
  • Network access: Home networking is not just for computers anymore, but will extend to the entertainment system. The RCA Home Theatre Music Jukebox is an amplified DVD home theatre system that acts a lot like an MP3 recorder. What with a 20GB hard drive, it rips CDs, and has a graphical on-screen display for creating laylists. This is a seriously wired machine. With Internet connectivity via broadband or dial-up to RCA's OpenGlobe, users can gain access to artist bios and discographies. Yet again we see the convergence of media types into one merged technology.
  • Hard drive: Currently, hard drive size is running between 20GB on the low end to 80GB on the high end. As new generations of product follow, those sizes will only increase. Hard drives make for fluid storage, where media can be edited, watched and recorded simultaneously, burning onto more expensive DVD media.

    It's important to remember that all this machine smartness is happening without a general-purpose computer attached to anything. Intelligence without booting up is a refreshing thing. That's why they're called Smart DVD recorders.

    Beware the Format Bog
    There is one sticky wicket in all this techno-delight, and that is the bewildering fuzzball of conflicting standards for recording DVD media. Just neglecting to notice whether your discs have a "+" or a "-" in their name can spell the difference between compatibility and frustration during the burning process. Until the marketplace sorts out this format war by killing off a standard or two, machines like the Sony RDR-GX7, that provide multi-format support, are well worth considering. Even so, it looks at this point like the two major formats may be able to co-exist. And when you want to share your DVDs with standard DVD players, the player may not care at all which format was selected for the burn.

    In the end upgrading to the new generation of smart DVD recorders is about adding information, customization, and precision to your media recording activities. The way you go about organizing, retrieving, storing, and viewing your video is going to change. It makes sense.

    Now that we've crossed over into the 21st Century, shouldn't we be acting like it? Let's get smart.

    [Sidebar]
    At the Consumer Electronics Show, held in Las Vegas in January 2003, many electronics companies, large and small, announced Smart DVD recorders. See their respective websites for further information. Here's the rundown.

    Philips showed the DVDR75, DVDR80, and included the LX9000R, a home theater system. Suggested retail prices are $699, $799 and $1,299 respectively. The Philips machines support the DVD+RW format. www.philips.com

    Sony rolled out the RDR-GX7 DVD recorder. Suggested retail price is about $800. It's a multiple capability machine recording in the DVD-RW and DVD+RW formats. www.sony.com

    RCA offered the DRC8000N DVD recorder. Suggested retail price is $599. It supports the DVD+RW format. www.rca.com

    Panasonic had the DMR-E50 DVD recorder on display. Suggested retail price of $600. It supports the DVD-R/RAM formats and has Time Slip and Chasing Playback functions. www.panasonic.com

    Pioneer introduced the DVR-7000 DVD recorder with a suggested retail price is $2,000. It supports the DVD-R/RW formats and has an internal tuner. www.pioneerelectronics.com

    Toshiba hawked the RD-X2, which is a DVD video recorder with a hard disk with a suggested retail price is $1,500. It supports the DVD-R/RAM formats. www.toshiba.com

    CyQ've displayed the PV-2400i DVD recorder with FireWire input. A suggested retail price was not available at press time. It supports the DVD+R/RW formats. www.met.com.tw